Do You Recommend Natural or Lab-Grown Diamonds / Gemstones for a Custom Design?

How to Choose the Right Stone for a Custom Jewelry Piece

Choosing the center stone of your bespoke jewelry design is a deeply personal decision. It is about more than just the sparkle of the stone – it represents your values, your priorities, and how you envision wearing your piece for years to come. Whether you’re searching for the best diamond for engagement ring or simply the best stone for everyday wear, your choice should align with what matters most to you. At Olertis, we believe that your choice should be based on your unique preferences.

Stone Selection Guide

Natural vs Lab-Grown Comparison Appearance & Durability How Lab Stones Are Created Natural vs Lab Price Differences Olertis Selection Process FAQ: Diamonds & Gemstones

Why are U.S. Clients Comparing Natural and Lab-Grown Stones in 2025

Lab-Grown Diamonds have gone from being a novelty to becoming a mainstream alternative to natural diamonds. By 2025, they now represent nearly half of all engagement ring diamond center stones sold in many U.S. retail segments. This shift has been driven by consumers who are prioritizing transparency regarding the origin of the stone, wanting larger stones, and having a better price-to-size ratio. While some consumers still prefer natural diamonds due to their rarity, their rich history, and potential long-term appreciation, at Olertis, we believe that you should have the opportunity to make an informed decision on what is best for you, free from external influence or pressure.

Appearance, Quality & Everyday-Wear Durability

The appearance of modern lab-grown diamonds is virtually identical to that of natural diamonds. Lab-grown diamonds often show fewer visible inclusions due to controlled growth conditions, making them perfect for clean, brilliant bespoke jewelry. Natural stones on the other hand, have inherent characteristics within the stone (the “fingerprints of earth”) that many people see as a part of the gemstone’s unique personality.

Both types of diamonds perform extremely well in terms of diamond durability and longevity for everyday wear, making either option suitable as a diamond for daily wear or for a custom engagement ring. Lab-grown diamonds share the same hardness as natural diamonds (10 on the Mohs scale), though some HPHT-grown stones may contain metallic inclusions, which should be considered when assessing their structural integrity. Ultimately, the main decision comes down to whether you prefer a larger, cleaner lab-grown diamond or the legacy and history associated with a natural gemstone.

Create Your Personal Jewelry

18K Yellow Gold Diamond and Sapphire Wedding Bands Waves Sky and Stars. Custom Wedding Bands. US Custom Wedding Bands, Bespoke Gold & Platinum Bands 18K Yellow Gold Round Clear and Yellow Diamond Ruby and Citrine Leaf Dangle Earrings. Custom Earrings. US Custom Earrings, Bespoke Fine Earrings in Gold & Platinum 18K Yellow Gold Diamond and Emerald Floral Bracelet with a Hiding Monkey. Custom Bracelets. US Custom Bracelets, Bespoke Gold & Platinum Bracelet Design 18K Yellow Gold Diamond and Ruby Sun with Beams Pendant on a chain. Custom Pendants. US Custom Pendants, Bespoke Gold & Platinum Pendant Design 18K Yellow Gold Sapphire and Amethyst Straight Barbells with Grapes. Custom Body Piercing Jewelry. US Custom Body Piercing Jewelry, Bespoke Fine Piercing Jewelry Custom Jewelry Design Service. Personalized jewelry development. Creation of sketches. 3D jewelry modeling. US Custom Jewelry Design, Bespoke 3D & CAD Jewelry Design 18K White Gold Round Sapphire and Clear Marquise Diamond Leaf Tree Branch Necklace. Custom Necklace. US Custom Necklaces, Bespoke Fine Necklace Design in the US 18K White Gold Blue and Clear Diamond Crown Engagement Ring. Custom Engagement Ring. US Custom Engagement Rings, Bespoke Diamond & Gemstone Designs 18K Yellow Gold Diamond and Amethyst Octopus Brooch. We make jewelry pins and brooch jewelry of any complexity. Custom Brooches and Pins. US Custom Brooches & Pins, Bespoke Fine Jewelry Design 18K Yellow Gold Round-Cut Diamond and Pear-Cut Emerald Chain. Custom Chain. US Custom Chains, Bespoke Gold & Platinum Chains 18K White Gold Diamond and Sapphire Eagle Ring. Custom Men's Jewelry. US Custom Men’s Jewelry, Bespoke Rings, Pendants & Chains 18K Yellow Gold Round Diamond and Sapphire Tie Clip. Custom Cufflinks & Tie Clips. US Custom Cufflinks & Tie Clips, Bespoke Men’s Jewelry 18K Yellow and White Gold Diamond and Ruby Elephant's Head With Tusks Ring. Custom Ring. US Custom Rings, Bespoke Gold & Platinum Ring Design

How Lab-Grown Diamonds and Gemstones Are Created (HPHT, CVD, Hydrothermal)

Clients often ask us how lab-grown diamonds are made. Here is a simplified explanation of the process:

Lab-diamonds are created using two primary methods: HPHT (High-Pressure-High-Temperature) and CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition). Color gemstones such as Sapphires, Rubies, Emeralds, etc., are primarily grown using hydrothermal or flux-growth methods. These methods mimic the natural growth process of gemstones, but occur under controlled conditions, producing gemstones with consistent clarity and color suitable for fine jewelry.

An oval lab-grown ruby, a natural sapphire and a diamond lie on the sand. How to Choose the Right Stone for a Custom Jewelry Piece. US

Natural vs Lab-Grown: U.S. Price Differences for Custom Jewelry

There are significant price disparities between natural diamonds/gemstones and lab-grown diamonds/gemstones, particularly at the same quality level. Generalized US Retail Price Trends are:

  • 1 carat clear diamonds: lab-grown diamonds usually cost 70–90% less than equivalent quality natural diamonds. A typical 1-carat lab-grown diamond may cost approximately $1,000, while an equivalent quality natural diamond could start at $4,000+.
  • 1-carat colored gems — rubies, emeralds, sapphires: lab-grown versions usually cost 70–90% less than natural counterparts. For example, a good quality lab-grown sapphire of nice color/clarity may retail between $200–$600 per carat, whereas a comparable quality natural sapphire — especially from a premium source — may retail in the $950–$2,200 per carat range (for commercially fine blue sapphires), and potentially much higher depending on saturation and cut. Premium-quality rubies and emeralds often fetch $2,600–$4,200 per carat (and higher), while comparable quality lab-grown options may sell for a fraction of that amount. Ultra-premium rubies (e.g., Burmese) may reach $10,000+ per carat; emeralds can also exceed this range but only in rare, exceptional cases.
  • Alternatives: Stones such as Moissanite or other synthetic stones may be purchased at lower prices, however, these types of stones fall into a completely separate category and do not replicate the chemical and structural properties of diamonds.

Why the large gap? Natural gemstones remain relatively expensive due to limited availability, mining costs, and variable clarity and color. Lab-grown stones enjoy advantages in manufacturing scalability, predictable quality, and reduced supply chain constraints, particularly since the U.S. saw a surge in lab-grown diamond production over the last 3–4 years, driving prices downward and increasing the gap.

At Olertis, when you commission custom jewelry, we always provide two price estimates: one for natural diamonds and one for lab-grown. This way, you can compare your budget options: either a larger/cleaner lab-grown stone or a smaller, but natural one. The percentages above reflect general market trends, we will always give you the most current pricing for your custom jewelry project.

An engagement ring with a lab-grown diamond and natural sapphires lies on the sand. Do You Recommend Natural or Lab-Grown Diamonds / Gemstones for a Custom Design? US

Olertis’ Transparent Stone-Selection Process

At Olertis, we operate on a client-centered, transparent basis. From the outset of your custom jewelry project, we provide you with pricing for both natural and lab-grown stones. Once we have discussed your goals (whether you are looking for investment potential, a future family heirloom, a particular aesthetic/style, or the greatest possible visual impact for your budget), we will collaborate with you to select the appropriate gemstone/design that best meets those goals. We will provide you with objective evaluations of the pros and cons of each option. All aspects of that decision (including the stone’s origin, certification, grade, specification, etc.) will then be documented in your agreement with complete transparency and accountability.

We will never direct you to “our favorite”. Ultimately, the decision is up to you. Our role is to assist you in finding the right balance between beauty, budget, ethics, and long-term significance so that your custom jewelry is a reflection of your story, not ours.

FAQ: U.S. Client Questions About Diamonds and Gemstones

When deciding between natural and lab-grown, clients often weigh several factors:

Q Will the stone appreciate in value?
Generally speaking, natural stones tend to hold their value longer than lab-grown. While the resale market for lab-grown diamonds is still developing, it is not as robust as the market for natural stones.
Q Are lab-grown stones more environmentally friendly/ethically sourced?
Some consumers opt for lab-grown for ethically-based reasons (to avoid mining, conflict-free origin), however, lab-grown diamond production still consumes energy, and the environmental impact depends on the manufacturer’s practices.
Q What about certifications and documentation?
Olertis provides fully accredited gemological certification for both natural and lab-grown stones (such as GIA, IGI, GCAL), depending on the type of stone and client preference.
Q Are lab-grown stones suitable for heirloom pieces?
Yes – technically. However, many consumers seeking to create multi-generational heirlooms still prefer natural diamonds for their rarity and symbolism.
Q Can I tell if a stone is lab-grown without special equipment?
No. Only specialized equipment used by professional gem graders can reliably differentiate lab-grown diamonds from natural.

To make the decision-making process easier, we typically compare the equivalent lab-grown option to a 1-carat natural diamond, demonstrating the trade-offs in terms of size, clarity, and value. This comparison helps clients understand which option might be the best diamond for engagement ring based on their priorities.